BlurPicture
Effects
Guides

Honesty

Why a redaction should look redacted

A covering does two jobs: it hides a detail, and it tells the reader that something is hidden. The second job matters as much as the first.

A bar is a statement

A solid bar says: something was here, and you are not being shown it.

That sentence protects the reader as well as you. Someone looking at a screenshot of a payment with the account number barred knows the screenshot is partial. Someone looking at the same screenshot with the number seamlessly painted out sees a payment with no account number — a document that never existed — and may rely on it.

Where invisible removal goes wrong

  • Evidence and complaints: a screenshot that looks complete but is not can mislead the very person you are trying to convince.
  • Receipts and statements: a total with a seamless gap where a line was looks like a different transaction.
  • Photos of people: a passer-by erased from a scene changes what happened there; covering their face does not.
  • Your own later self: a month on, you may not remember what you removed from a file that looks untouched.

What this site does instead

Every privacy covering here is visible by design: a solid fill in ink, black, white or the average colour of what it covers, a mosaic, or a blur — all of them plainly coverings. There is no “remove and fill in the background” tool on this site, and the reason is this page. If you need a covering to blend into a white document, choose the white fill: it is still fully opaque and still reads as a covering at a glance.

Make the covering do its first job too

Looking redacted is not the same as being redacted. A blur looks like a covering and can still be searched; a mosaic keeps the large shapes of what was there. For anything that would cause harm in the wrong hands, use the solid fill — the photo redactor opens with it — and if you were sent a covered picture, the blur checker measures what is left inside it.

Questions

Isn't it neater to remove the number so nobody notices?
Neater, yes; more honest, no. If the reader cannot tell anything was removed, they will read the picture as complete — a bank statement with a balance and no account number, a receipt with a total and no name — and draw conclusions from it as if nothing were missing.
Does a black bar look unprofessional?
It looks deliberate, which is the point. If a dark bar is too loud on a white page, the white or average fill colour is just as opaque and draws less attention, while still being plainly a covering.
Can an invisible removal be undone?
A removal that paints new content over the pixels destroys what was there just as a bar does. The problem is not recovery but trust: the picture now shows something that was not there, and nobody looking at it knows.

The tool this was written for is on the front page.

Blur a photo