Choosing
Blur, mosaic or solid
Three coverings, one rule for choosing between them, and a table for when the rule feels too strict.
The rule, before the table
Ask how many different originals could have produced what you are looking at. If the answer is a number somebody could count to, use the solid fill.
That is the whole decision. A face in a crowd of strangers has an enormous answer set — it could be any of billions of people and nobody has the list. A face in a photograph captioned with a school and a year has an answer set of about thirty, and a blur that leaves the hair, the height and the position intact narrows it further. The covering did not change; the context did.
The table
| What is in the region | Use | Why |
|---|---|---|
| A stranger's face in a holiday photograph | Blur or mosaic, if you prefer how it looks | Nobody has the candidate list and nobody is going to build one. This is politeness rather than protection, and it is allowed to look good. |
| A child, anywhere | Solid fill | The cost of being wrong is not yours to accept, and the candidate set is almost always small — a class, a club, a family. |
| Faces in a work or school photograph | Solid fill | The group is named by the caption. A face-shaped smear of the right size in the right place is a strong hint when there are thirty candidates. |
| A number plate | Solid fill | Short string, known alphabet, standardised typeface, enumerable. The worst case in the subject. |
| A bank balance or an account number | Solid fill | Formatted, low-entropy, often check-summed. Half the answer set is gone before anyone looks at a pixel. |
| A signature | Solid fill | A signature is a shape, and a blurred shape is still a shape. It is also the one thing here that somebody might want to copy rather than read. |
| An identity number on a document | Solid fill | Same reasoning as an account number, with the added problem that the format is published and the covering is often applied to a large, sharp photograph. |
| A street name or house number | Solid fill | The answer set is a list of streets, which anybody can download. |
| A logo or a brand you would rather not advertise | Blur or mosaic | Nothing is at stake. Choose whichever looks less like a mistake. |
Seven of nine rows say the same thing, and that is not a table that failed to be interesting. It is the finding. The interesting cases are the two at the ends.
The thresholds the tool uses
The verdicts in the editor and the blur checker use the figures below. The first two rows come from the evidence page, regenerated from the engine on every build, so this table, the evidence and the tool cannot disagree.
| Covering | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Solid fill | Destroyed | Every candidate number produced the same covered picture: nothing to search. |
| Mosaic | Weak — structure survives | Every block size the slider makes over a line of type (up to 0.36× the letter height) was read back in full. Partial reads began at 0.5×; the test's search first failed at 1.5×. |
| Blur | Weak — reversible in principle | Every radius the slider makes over a line of type (up to 0.21× the letter height) was read back in full. Partial reads continued to 1×; the test's search first failed at 2×. |
| Checker: flat | Nothing left inside | Brightness varies by less than 2.5 levels across the box, JPEG grain included. |
| Checker: mosaic | Structure survives | At least 60% of columns and rows are flat inside blocks, and block edges fall on a regular grid. |
| Checker: smooth | Reversible in principle | A one-pixel step is less than 0.36 of a four-pixel step; sharp type is about half. |
Why the tool defaults to the boring answer
Most tools in this area default to a blur, because a blur is what the word in the search box said and because it photographs well in a product screenshot. The cost of that default is paid quietly and later, by somebody who assumed that covering a thing meant the thing was covered.
This one defaults to the solid fill and makes the other two a deliberate step down, with the reason printed beside the control rather than in a help page. It is a worse screenshot and a better tool. The full argument about what a blur actually leaves behind is in can blurred text be read.
Questions about the three coverings
What is the actual difference between a blur and a mosaic?
Is pixelation reversible?
Which one looks best?
Can I use different coverings in the same picture?
The tool this was written for is on the front page.
Blur a photo